5 Ways Managers Can Prepare for Performance Reviews All Year

November 18, 2026

Your employee has been thinking about their performance review for days. They’ve replayed this past year in their head over and over again. They’ve thought about the projects that went well, the one that didn’t, that comment you made back in the spring that to them felt like it came out of left field without any explanation. 

Now here they are walking into the performance meeting with you. They are nervous, not sure what to expect.

You’re on the other side of the desk, feeling flustered. This is one of 20 performance reviews you need to finish over the next 2 weeks, on top of everything else that has to be done by year-end. You’ve been in their shoes, and you know how much this matters to them. You care, a lot. But juggling a full workload and the pressure to get it all done on time is hard. And chances are you were never shown how to do these reviews effectively, so you aren’t sure what all you should, or should not say, in their review. 

But it matters. Gallup’s data found that less than half of employees (47%) strongly agree they know what is expected of them at work. When people aren’t sure where they stand all year, a review can feel like a surprise, and not a good one. 

A good performance review is a summary of the year, not a surprise. That means the best prep doesn’t start in late Q4. It starts months before the review, and it carries through the conversation itself.

Many organizations are in the middle of performance review season or getting ready for it. If you’re feeling a little in the dark on how to get your reviews ready and completed, this blog is for you. Let’s look at 5 ways to prepare for performance reviews all year and make next year’s process a little easier. 

 

1. Track and Document All Year, Not Just late Q4

Whether you are completing one performance review or 20, feeling like you can complete the documentation can be heavy. You’re trying to recall what happened 10 months ago up through last week. Even the person with the best memory can struggle. 

That’s why it’s important to be consistent with your documentation throughout the year. A great way to capture progress is to conduct consistent 1:1s with your employees. Here you can not only address how your employee is feeling, progressing and producing, you can agree on clear metrics. This way both you and your employee know where things stand long before the review. 

An easy practice is to keep a file folder, physical or virtual, for each employee. See something great – jot it down. Did you address a concern 4 months ago with your team member – document it. Things add up when they happen throughout the year. Then, when it’s time to complete the performance review, you’re looking back at what happened, not starting from scratch or only remembering something recent that occurred.

There’s a saying that if something wasn’t documented, it didn’t happen. Plus, it can be hard to deal with later, especially when you are realizing a pattern in negative behavior or performance. Here’s an easy-to-follow framework to know what to document:

  • Date
  • What happened (observable behavior)
  • Impact on team/organization/customer
  • Expectation discussed
  • Next steps and follow-up date

Here’s what this looks like in practice:

“On May 12, 2026, Joe missed a deadline on a project. This was the second time a deadline was missed on this project. This caused a delay in the completion of the project and our client had to wait on receiving data. We talked about the upcoming deadlines and set a plan for Joe to notify in advance if a deadline is at risk, so that we can adjust accordingly. We’ll check in on project status at our next 1:1 meeting on May 25, 2026.”

 

2. Recognize Wins Along the Way

If the only feedback your employee hears all year is about the misses and what went wrong, you are missing out on opportunities for development and growth. And, when it comes time to conduct a performance review, it is going to feel very heavy and negative when chances are there are many positive reasons to recognize your employee.  

Sharing with an employee something you recognized can be extremely meaningful to an employee. They may feel they were just doing their job and may not realize how significant their actions were. A win is also a chance to reflect. What went well? What made it work? And how can you do it again?

Be specific. A generic “great job” is easy to tune out. Saying exactly what you saw and why it mattered, such as “the way you walked the new team member through that process made her first week so much easier,” tells your employee their work was noticed. It doesn’t have to be a grand gesture. It can be a quick conversation, a shout-out in a team meeting, or a minute at the start of your 1:1.  

Celebrate those wins when they happen, and be sure to add them to your documentation file.

Recognizing wins and work done well is another way to increase engagement with your employees. Employees who feel noticed tend to feel more connected and engaged to their work and have more trust in you.

________________________________________________________________________________

Want to see how performance conversations connect to engagement? See striveHR’s blog The Real Connection Between Performance Management and Employee Engagement.

________________________________________________________________________________

 

3. Spot Patterns Early

No one likes to have hard conversations. They can be uncomfortable and awkward even for the most confident leader. But being honest and open to talking about patterns as they show up, instead of waiting to see if they happen again, can lead to growth for your employees.

It’s best to bring up a pattern or concern early. This gives you an open door to ask questions for clarity of why this is happening, and it gives your employee an opportunity to adjust while there’s still time.

Let’s face it, we’d prefer to celebrate wins. And one big win makes it easy to overlook a pattern that’s building in the wrong direction. Here, two things can be true. Someone can deliver a great result and still have an opportunity to improve. Wins and opportunities can be held in the same conversation, as long as there is intent and support behind both discussions.

 

4. Coach in the Moment

As a manager, you spend a lot of your time giving direction, evaluating daily performance and being on the lookout for things going off the rails. Many managers will say that if things do get off course, it’s easier to fix the issue themselves or keep focused on work with the intent to address problems later.

These situations generate missed opportunities for coaching. Rather than overlooking a problem or saving it for later, take time to make small corrections in real time. It’s then easier for the employee to connect to the situation, and easier to act on, rather than a long list of concerns months later. When a coaching moment comes up, name it, talk it through, and use it as a guide for improvement.

Coaching moments can be subtle. Instead of giving direction, ask your employee “What do you think the next step should be?” Or, when a mistake occurs, use it as a teachable moment rather than correcting it right away. Ask your employee what they would change, and why rather than fixing it for them. 

Coaching isn’t an event. It’s built into how you lead, every day, even in the small moments. Coaching opportunities present themselves often. One great place to focus on coaching your employees is during your 1:1 meetings. 

________________________________________________________________________________

Not sure what to cover in your 1:1s? A great place to start is by reading the striveHR blog Ignite Employee Engagement Through 1:1 Conversations. 

________________________________________________________________________________

 

5. Make the Review a Conversation

Rather than delivering a performance review, think of it as a conversation, one where both you and your employee are providing feedback. This is a time where you are discussing wins, opportunities to improve, and growth in an open, meaningful dialogue. This is  not the time for surprises.

Ask your employee to come with their own list of what they’re proud of from the year and what they’d like to talk about. Questions that can get the conversation going are:

  • What are you most proud of this year?
  • What got in your way?
  • Where would you like to grow next year?

Imagine what your performance review process will look like next year when you have documents throughout the year, kept notes, and invited your employee to share their own feedback throughout the year. A conversation like this builds trust, and it opens the door to more conversations long after review season is over.

 

Start Now for Next Year’s Reviews

Here’s a quick reference to help you be set up for success for your next year with performance reviews:

  • Set up your files now. Keep one folder per employee, with a simple template using the framework above. Virtual or paper works – you’re more likely to do this more consistently if it’s in a format that is easier for you.
  • Put it on the calendar. Schedule your recurring 1:1s with each team member on a consistent basis, weekly, biweekly or monthly. 
  • Start the year with clear expectations. Talk through what’s expected and what success looks like, so that your employees aren’t guessing what you expect.
  • Invite employees to keep their own list of accomplishments through the year.
  • Block time on your calendar quarterly to look back through each file so that you aren’t allowing issues to be overlooked.

And if you’re reading this in November without a file? You’re not behind. Start where you are. Look back through your calendar, email, and project notes, and ask your employees what they’re proud of this year. Then start your file for next year.

 

A Review You’ll Both Be Ready For 

A good performance review isn’t a single meeting. It’s a summary of a year of what went well, what needs improvement, and the moments worth celebrating. Look back at the notes you kept, the recognition you gave, the patterns you addressed before they became an issue, and the coaching along the way that opened the door for growth.

When managers do this work, employees walk in ready for the conversation, and perhaps look forward to it. 

It also makes your job easier. When the work happens all year, review season stops feeling like a scramble. You aren’t trying to remember what happened 10 months ago, because it’s already in your file. 

And you don’t have to do this alone. After many years in HR, I can tell you that HR and leadership want you and your employees to have a good experience with performance reviews.

 

Want to strengthen your meetings with your team members throughout the year? Download the Manager’s Guide to Meaningful 1:1 Conversations for guided questions and approaches that keep performance conversations thriving between formal reviews.   

laura kamark circle headshot circle 1

Hello, I’m Angie

I help business leaders and HR professionals improve their workplace culture and increase employee engagement so that they can focus on running their organization.

Website Content Planning Workbook
What if the journey of applying for the award brought more positives to your organization
than simply
earning the trophy?

Sign up now to learn the perks you will get on
your way to becoming
an award-winning workplace!

I respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

Website Content Planning Workbook 800 x 800 px

Do you want to be the hero of your organization?

You are ready to improve your company culture. You want to create a great workplace environment. You know how important a strong corporate culture is to the success of an organization.

YOU'VE COME TO THE RIGHT PLACE!

Sign up to get immediate access to 10 ideas you can act on today that create a positive impact on your corporate culture!